Blaming teachers for Nevada's ranking in education performance is akin to blaming cashiers for stores closing due to declining profits – the responsibility lies with leadership, not the frontline workers. (Photo: Ronda Churchill/Nevada Current)

Policy, politics and progressive commentary

I recently took a leave of absence from teaching after a series of reports of workplace bullying, made by myself and colleagues, were not only ignored by our district superiors but dismissed by human resources. I was informed that such behavior is an inherent part of any industry (gossiping, backstabbing, shaming, etc), and it was implied that perhaps I was being too sensitive.

Given the culture of the Clark County School District (CCSD), their response shouldn’t have surprised me, and under normal circumstances, I would have been able to move on. But this last betrayal of trust became the straw that broke the camel’s back for me, as I was hanging on to my teaching career by a literal thread. 

Like all educators, I “knew what I signed up for,” but wanted to make a difference and was fully aware I would never become wealthy financially. I loved teaching and cherish the joy I felt when students walked away from my classroom with more confidence in themselves. However, what I hadn’t prepared for were the cruel politics, misogyny, gaslighting, and hostile work environment that ultimately overshadowed my “why.”

Even with advanced degrees and certifications, we’re often treated like “glorified babysitters,” as highlighted in a recent court motion where teachers allegedly called in sick as a form of protest. In her ruling, the judge admonished teachers, saying parents “need to go to work and feed their families” and are “counting on you guys to show up,” and “do your job.” In other words, parents need teachers to watch their kids. As a parent myself, I empathize with those needing childcare, but this perception is insulting and disregards the complex responsibilities of licensed educators. 

Unable to strike in the state of Nevada, we face a no-win situation in the struggle for improved pay and working conditions. While our contentious contract dispute has finally been resolved and the Clark County Education Association once again prevailed, CCSD educators have been teaching without a contract since the beginning of the school year. In an attempt to do my part, I wrote op-eds and letters to the editor and even created a TikTok account to advocate. While many in the public were supportive, a significant portion expressed palpable vitriol and misogyny. I was attacked in the Las Vegas Review Journal, and messages of “stop whining” and “just quit” were regular comments on my social media feed. However, my experience pales compared to a kindergarten teacher facing legal repercussions for speaking out. Deputy District Attorney, Brian Casper, is seeking jail time for her charge of “disturbing the peace.” 

This feels alarmingly like the historical injustices of the Salem Witch Trials which specifically targeted outspoken women. The societal manipulation and shame associated with advocating for fair treatment is a tool to silence educators, most of whom are female.

While the income disparity is problematic, it’s not always the pay that drives teachers away. Demands to simultaneously address learning loss and the social-emotional needs of students post-COVID-19 while juggling crowded classrooms have been daunting. To make matters worse, teachers have been stripped of the authority to hold students accountable for behavior and grades in an effort to create an “appearance” of widespread academic success and reduced disciplinary actions. In 2021-2022, for example, expulsion grounds in CCSD were limited to incidents involving weapons (that was since changed, but only after a teacher was brutally attacked and raped by a student). Additionally, a new grade policy mandates a minimum of 50% final grade, regardless of effort, and hampers incentivizing formative classroom activities. This has lowered student engagement, increased classroom disruptions, and hindered learning for everyone. The toll on educators is immense and I experienced my first panic attack in the 2021-22 school year as a result.

Those who were opposed to giving educators the contract we were fighting for point to Nevada’s dismal ranking in academic performance and unfairly place the blame solely on teachers. It’s akin to blaming cashiers for stores closing due to declining profits – the responsibility lies with leadership, not the frontline workers. Yet, many hold teachers accountable for failing schools despite our being at the mercy of those who make decisions on how we do our jobs.

I am no mathematician, but even I can connect the dots: CCSD’s decline in student achievement and steady rise in teacher vacancies has everything to do with failed leadership. Despite the data, and prominent legislators and educators calling for the superintendent’s removal, however, district officials refuse to take responsibility. While the approved raises for educators may entice new talent to the district, student achievement and educator retention will continue to decline so long as this issue is not addressed. 

As I reflect on my experiences, I recognize that my story is not unique and is symbolic of the issues that plague educators nationwide. The strain on our mental health and the burden of shouldering systemic failures is a narrative familiar to many teachers. But as I considered returning to the classroom after my leave of absence, I came to the realization that the last thing I should do is go back to the place that broke me. 

A teacher’s work environment is our children’s learning environment. I implore the public to lend their voices to the collective outcry for change in education by voting for school board trustees and other policymakers who recognize the importance of empowering educators to shape the direction of our classrooms. Your engagement will ensure a brighter future for both teachers and students alike.

The post The ones failing the hardest at CCSD are its leaders appeared first on Nevada Current.

CCSD Superintendent Jesus Jara wondering whether he can pay teachers in fishsticks. (Photo: Camalot Todd/Nevada Current)

Policy, politics and progressive commentary

If the public wants to know why Clark County School District educators have been shutting down board meetings and are ready to engage in “work actions,” they need to look no further than our very own Superintendent Dr. Jesus Jara.  

Despite what some in the media are claiming, the average educator in Las Vegas earns substantially less than individuals in other professions with similar levels of education and experience. Given the average price of a home is $440,000, utilities are approximately $400 per month, and gas is $4.50 per gallon, it is no surprise that CCSD still has 1,200 teacher vacancies.

The Nevada Legislature recognized the need to address the teacher shortage, so they not only increased education funding by $2.6 billion dollars, but they passed Senate Bill 231, which earmarks $250 million specifically for raises. CCSD would receive the bulk of that funding, so it would stand to reason, then, that CCSD can afford to pay educators what they deserve.

But instead of using the funding to address the fact that thousands of children have once again started the school year without a licensed educator, Supt. Jara chose to waste millions of dollars this past summer creating new “associate” superintendent positions in order to micromanage schools, several more million on blindsiding educators with useless new curriculum without researching its effectiveness, and gave every administrator an average raise of $27,000 over two years.

Meanwhile, Jara’s latest proposal for educators is nearly 10% less than what we are asking for, includes a sunset clause of 2025 (which means our pay can go back down in two years), is sneaking in an extra 57 hours to our workload, and getting rid of our current salary table and replacing it with a new one that makes advancement much more difficult unless educators earn a Ph.D. 

This comes as no surprise, however, because Jara has a history of rewarding only those most loyal to him while spending millions of dollars to bribe those who are not. In 2021, for example, he gave significant raises to his top staff members, the most notable of which was Chief Financial Officer Jason Goudie, who received a generous increase of $45,000 per year. Then he and Goudie “pulled a Godfather tactic” as columnist Carrie Kaufman put it in the Nevada Current, and spent millions to buy out principals who were close to retirement and whose “vision” did not align with his.

One has to wonder how Jara and Goudie continue to find money to fulfill their own political/professional agendas, yet claim time and time again that they do not have the money to pay teachers. According to state Sen. Carrie Ann Buck, “It’s so easy to do the math, but yet again CCSD does not take care of their people.” “The money is there with $2 billion going to education, & the majority to CCSD, so why is the superintendent not negotiating in good faith? Most charter schools gave a 20% increase. What is going on in CCSD?” 

Actions speak louder than words, and Dr. Jara has done nothing to incentivize working for CCSD as an educator. He has single-handedly created one of the most toxic and hostile work environments I have ever experienced and continues to fuel the fire with every self-serving decision he makes. This is why morale is so low and CCSD is experiencing a crisis in terms of the number of teacher vacancies they have yet to fill. Perhaps it is because of his lack of actual teaching experience, but he has made it abundantly clear that he thinks very little of educators and has no idea what it’s like to be a classroom teacher. 

The bottom line is this: If teachers can achieve unattainable results with inadequate resources, then Jara and his sycophant Jason Goudie can do the same with the abundance of money gifted to them by the Nevada Legislature. 

This column has been revised to remove a reference to average salaries.

The post It’s not a lack of funding… it’s Jara appeared first on Nevada Current.